Article Credit: https://www.veterinarypracticenews.com/debating-raw-diets-january-2019/
Written By: By Brennen McKenzie, MA, MSc, VMD, cVMA
In spite of resistance from most veterinarians and from public health authorities, the popularity of raw meat-based diets for dogs and cats continues to grow.1,2 Raw feeders have a range of ideas about nutrition, but they typically believe that raw diets are healthier and more “natural” than cooked diets, and they often suspect conventional commercial diets are unsafe or a possible cause of disease.3,4
Unfortunately, it is not only pet owners who hold such beliefs. Though they are a minority, some veterinarians promote raw feeding and attack the safety and nutritional value of cooked commercial diets.5,6
Surveys show that pet owners who feed raw diets are less likely to trust nutrition advice from veterinarians and are also less likely to adhere to other recommendations (e.g. vaccination and parasite prevention) than owners who feed traditional commercial diets.3,1 Veterinarians who promote raw feeding and condemn conventional diets are also often suspicious of vaccines and other science-based medical therapies, and frequently advocate alternative medical practices.5,7,8
Though individual beliefs vary, there is a general trend for raw diets to be appealing to pet owners or veterinarians who believe more “natural” diets and medical approaches are safer and better than conventional medical and nutritional practices. These beliefs are predicated on questionable concepts and are not supported by convincing research evidence.
The most common rationale for feeding raw is that this is a more natural diet to which dogs and cats have been adapted by evolution and which should, therefore, be healthier for them. Taxonomically, dogs and cats are carnivores (though dogs are functionally omnivores) and their ancestors ate live prey and carrion, so they must be designed for a diet as close as possible to that of wild carnivores. Some raw-diet advocates extend this argument by claiming that anatomic and physiological similarities between domestic dogs and wolves imply dogs should be fed the same diet wolves eat in the wild and domestic cats should ideally eat whole prey as wild felines do.5
Raw diets are also claimed to have specific health effects ranging from better coat and stool quality to a lower risk of diabetes, allergies, cancer, and other serious diseases.8,9 Proponents of raw diets consistently argue that any risks are outweighed by these benefits.
The other major argument for feeding raw diets is that cooked commercial diets are nutritionally inadequate and unhealthy. Proponents of raw diets express concerns about the loss of nutrients in heating and processing, the dangerous health effects of grains and carbohydrates in commercial diets, and numerous purported toxins, ranging from by-products of processing to preservatives and other additives in canned and dry diets. Many chronic health problems are blamed on commercial pet food by raw-diet advocates.5,6,8
The idea raw diets should be beneficial because they are “natural” is simply an expression of the “appeal to nature fallacy,” the misconception that anything found in nature is inherently healthier than anything produced by humans. Illustrations of why this is false are easy to find. Consider, for example, that dysentery, smallpox, and rattlesnake venom are perfectly natural, and antibiotics, vaccines, and anti-venin are clearly artificial, yet there’s no doubt the latter are certainly better for health than the former.
It is also clear “natural” is not a synonym for “healthy” from the fact that parasitism, malnutrition, and infectious disease are rampant in wild animal populations and that life expectancy and health are nearly always superior for animals in appropriate captive environments.10 The diet of wild carnivores is simply the food they can get, not a perfect diet designed for long-term health. Experts in captive wild carnivore nutrition recommend commercial foods as a significant component of the overall diet for these species because such foods improve the safety and nutritional quality of the diet and the health of
Even if a species-typical diet in the wild were optimal for the health of wild carnivores, it is obvious dogs, at least, have evolved far from their wild ancestors and would not necessarily have the same dietary needs. Evidence shows many genetic, anatomic, and physiologic differences between domestic dogs and wild canids that result from selective pressures associated with living with humans, and these have altered their nutritional requirements and the foods that will best support long-term health.15–19
There is no compelling evidence for any of the specific health benefits claimed for raw diets, and there has been very little research investigating them.4,20 The few published studies of raw feeding have found various effects on physiologic and clinical parameters, but little sign of any significant health effects, so most health claims are purely anecdotal at this point.21–25
The claims about the hazards of commercial diets vary from implausible and completely unproven to legitimate, substantiated risks. Commercial diets can be a source of infectious diseases, and some cases of serious injury due to adulterants or other toxins have been seen.26,27 However, there is ample research evidence to support the nutritional value of properly formulated diets, and some evidence to support specific health benefits for some diets, such as renal and urolith dissolution diets.28–30 Millions of dogs and cats live long and healthy lives on commercial pet foods, so while they are not perfect or risk free, there is little reason to believe they are a major risk factor for disease in most animals, and there is certainly no research evidence to support this claim.
Unlike the benefits of raw diets, which are theoretical and unproven, the risks are well documented. Commercial raw diets that meet Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) standards are likely to be nutritionally complete, but many raw advocates feed home-prepared diets, and these diets are frequently nutritionally unbalanced and incomplete.4,31–35 The widespread use of bones in raw diets also presents a significant risk of dental fractures and gastrointestinal injury,36–40 though one study has suggested some possible benefits for dental health.41 Even wild carnivores are at risk for acute dental and gastrointestinal trauma from bones, as well as chronic tooth wear, and this can lead to the “natural” outcomes of suffering or death.42–44 Pet dogs and cats are at least as susceptible to this risk as wild carnivores, and the natural outcomes are clearly unacceptable to owners.
The most significant risk of raw diets is from food-borne infectious disease. Illness and death in cats and dogs, and in their owners, have been caused by pathogens found in raw pet diets.4,45–51 Although such pathogens can contaminate cooked diets as well, the risk is significantly higher for raw foods.27 While healthy, immunocompetent adult pets may be able to resist these organisms to some extent, there is no absolute immunity in dogs and cats to food-borne illness. Young, old, immunosuppressed animals, and their human caregivers, are at even higher risk.
There are no proven health benefits to raw diets, and most of the claims rest on dubious theoretical grounds and exaggerated fears about conventional cooked diets. There are, however, clear risks to feeding raw meat, including nutritional deficiencies or excesses, risk of injury from bones, and risk of severe infection and death in both pets and humans. While properly formulated raw diets can be nutritionally appropriate and the risks of infectious disease can be mitigated by scrupulous food handling, the established risks of raw diets and the complete lack of compelling evidence for any health benefits make the use of such diets a choice based on ideology or personal belief, not sound scientific evidence.
1 Gyles C. Raw food diets for pets. Can Vet J = La Rev Vet Can. 2017;58(6):537-539. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28588324. Accessed October 27, 2018.
2 Waters A. Raw diets: are we at a turning point? Vet Rec. 2017;181(15):384.2-384. doi:10.1136/vr.j4709
3 Morgan SK, Willis S, Shepherd ML. Survey of owner motivations and veterinary input of owners feeding diets containing raw animal products. PeerJ. 2017;5:e3031. doi:10.7717/peerj.3031
4 Freeman LM, Chandler ML, Hamper BA, Weeth LP. Current knowledge about the risks and benefits of raw meat-based diets for dogs and cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2013;243(11):1549-1558. doi:10.2460/javma.243.11.1549
5 Billinghurst I. Give Your Dog a Bone.; 1993. https://www.worldcat.org/title/give-your-dog-a-bone/oclc/973482033&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
6 Lonsdale T. Raw Meaty Bones. [NSW Australia]: Rivetco P/L; 2001. https://www.worldcat.org/title/raw-meaty-bones-promote-health/oclc/1040658362&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
7 Pitcairn RH, Pitcairn SH. Dr. Pitcairn’s Complete Guide to Natural Health for Dogs & Cats.; 2017. https://www.worldcat.org/title/dr-pitcairns-complete-guide-to-natural-health-for-dogs-cats/oclc/948336415&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
8 Dodds WJ, Laverdure D. Canine Nutrigenomics : The New Science of Feeding Your Dog for Optimum Health.; 2015. https://www.worldcat.org/title/canine-nutrigenomics-the-new-science-of-feeding-your-dog-for-optimum-health/oclc/890808034&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
9 Billinghurst I. Pointing the Bone at Cancer : In Dogs Cats and Humans.; 2016. https://www.worldcat.org/title/pointing-the-bone-at-cancer-in-dogs-cats-and-humans/oclc/964572415&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
10 Tidière M, Gaillard J-M, Berger V, et al. Comparative analyses of longevity and senescence reveal variable survival benefits of living in zoos across mammals. Sci Rep. 2016;6(1):36361. doi:10.1038/srep36361
11 Newton. Nutrition. In: Mexican Wolf Husbandry Manual. Silver Springs, MD: American Association of Zoos and Aquariums; 1995. https://nagonline.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Red-Wolf-Nutrition.pdf.
12 Waddell W. Nutrition. In: Red Wolf Husbandry Manual Guidelines for Captive Management. Silver Springs, MD: American Association of Zoos and Aquariums; 1998. https://nagonline.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Red-Wolf-Nutrition.pdf.
13 Allen M. Maned wolf nutritional management. In: Husbandry Manual for the Maned Wolf Chrysocyon Brachyurus. Silver Springs, MD: American Association of Zoos and Aquariums; 1995.
14 AZA Canid Tag. Large Canid (Canidae) Care Manual. Silver Springs, MD: American Association of Zoos and Aquariums; 2012. https://nagonline.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Large-Canid-Care-Manual-2012-NAG-EDIT.pdf.
15 Vilà C, Maldonado JE, Wayne RK. Phylogenetic relationships, evolution, and genetic diversity of the domestic dog. J Hered. 90(1):71-77. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9987908. Accessed October 27, 2018.
16 Wayne RK. Molecular evolution of the dog family. Trends Genet. 1993;9(6):218-224. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8337763. Accessed October 27, 2018.
17 Serpell J, Barrett P. The Domestic Dog : Its Evolution, Behavior and Interactions with People. Second edition.; 2017. https://www.worldcat.org/title/domestic-dog-its-evolution-behavior-and-interactions-with-people/oclc/987274028&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
18 Axelsson E, Ratnakumar A, Arendt M-L, et al. The genomic signature of dog domestication reveals adaptation to a starch-rich diet. Nature. 2013;495(7441):360-364. doi:10.1038/nature11837
19 Reiter T, Jagoda E, Capellini TD. Dietary Variation and Evolution of Gene Copy Number among Dog Breeds. 2016. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0148899
20 Schlesinger D, Joffe D. Raw Food Diets in Companion Animals: A Critical Review. Can Vet J. 2011;52(1):50-4.
21 Vester BM, Burke SL, Liu KJ, Dikeman CL, Simmons LG, Swanson KS. Influence of feeding raw or extruded feline diets on nutrient digestibility and nitrogen metabolism of African wildcats (Felis lybica). Zoo Biol. 2010;29(6):676-686. doi:10.1002/zoo.20305
22 Kerr KR, Vester Boler BM, Morris CL, Liu KJ, Swanson KS. Apparent total tract energy and macronutrient digestibility and fecal fermentative end-product concentrations of domestic cats fed extruded, raw beef-based, and cooked beef-based diets. J Anim Sci. 2012;90(2):515-522. doi:10.2527/jas.2010-3266
23 Beloshapka AN, Duclos LM, Vester Boler BM, Swanson KS. Effects of inulin or yeast cell-wall extract on nutrient digestibility, fecal fermentative end-product concentrations, and blood metabolite concentrations in adult dogs fed raw meat–based diets. Am J Vet Res. 2012;73(7):1016-1023. doi:10.2460/ajvr.73.7.1016
24 Kim J, An J-U, Kim W, Lee S, Cho S. Differences in the gut microbiota of dogs (Canis lupus familiaris) fed a natural diet or a commercial feed revealed by the Illumina MiSeq platform. Gut Pathog. 2017;9(1):68. doi:10.1186/s13099-017-0218-5
25 Sandri M, Dal Monego S, Conte G, Sgorlon S, Stefanon B. Raw meat based diet influences faecal microbiome and end products of fermentation in healthy dogs. BMC Vet Res. 2017;13(1):65. doi:10.1186/s12917-017-0981-z
26 Bischoff K, Rumbeiha WK. Pet Food Recalls and Pet Food Contaminants in Small Animals. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract. 2018;48(6):917-931. doi:10.1016/j.cvsm.2018.07.005
27 Nemser SM, Doran T, Grabenstein M, et al. Investigation of Listeria, Salmonella, and toxigenic Escherichia coli in various pet foods. Foodborne Pathog Dis. 2014;11(9):706-709. doi:10.1089/fpd.2014.1748
28 Council NR. Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press; 2006. doi:10.17226/10668
29 Association of American Feed Control Officials. 2018 Official Publication : Association of American Feed Control Officials Incorporated.; 2018. https://www.worldcat.org/title/2018-official-publication-association-of-american-feed-control-officials-incorporated/oclc/1023038973&referer=brief_results. Accessed October 27, 2018.
30 Davies M. Veterinary clinical nutrition: success stories: an overview. Proc Nutr Soc. 2016;75(03):392-397. doi:10.1017/S002966511600029X
31 Taylor MB, Geiger DA, Saker KE, Larson MM. Diffuse osteopenia and myelopathy in a puppy fed a diet composed of an organic premix and raw ground beef. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2009;234(8):1041-1048. doi:10.2460/javma.234.8.1041
32 Freeman LM, Michel KE. Veterinary Medicine Today Timely Topics in Nutrition Evaluation of raw food diets for dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2001;218(5):705-709. doi:10.2460/javma.2001.218.705
33 Lauten SD, Smith TM, Kirk CA, Bartges JW, Adams A WS. Computer Analysis of Nutrient Sufficiency of Published Home-Cooked Diets for Dogs and Cats. In: Proceedings of the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine Forum. Baltimore, MD; 2005.
34 Stockman J, Fascetti AJ, Kass PH, Larsen JA. Evaluation of recipes of home-prepared maintenance diets for dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2013;242(11):1500-1505. doi:10.2460/javma.242.11.1500
35 Larsen JA, Parks EM, Heinze CR, Fascetti AJ. Evaluation of recipes for home-prepared diets for dogs and cats with chronic kidney disease. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2012;240(5):532-538. doi:10.2460/javma.240.5.532
36 Robinson J, Gorrel C. The oral status of a pack of foxhounds fed a “natural” diet. In: Proceedings. Fifth World Veterinary Dental Congress. Birmingham, England; 1997.
37 Rousseau A, Prittie J, Broussard JD, Fox PR, Hoskinson J. Incidence and characterization of esophagitis following esophageal foreign body removal in dogs: 60 cases (1999?2003). J Vet Emerg Crit Care. 2007;17(2):159-163. doi:10.1111/j.1476-4431.2007.00227.x
38 Gianella P, Pfammatter NS, Burgener IA. Oesophageal and gastric endoscopic foreign body removal: complications and follow-up of 102 dogs. J Small Anim Pract. 2009;50(12):649-654. doi:10.1111/j.1748-5827.2009.00845.x
39 Frowde PE, Battersby IA, Whitley NT, Elwood CM. Oesophageal disease in 33 cats. J Feline Med Surg. 2011;13(8):564-569. doi:10.1016/j.jfms.2011.04.004
40 Thompson HC, Cortes Y, Gannon K, Bailey D, Freer S. Esophageal foreign bodies in dogs: 34 cases (2004-2009). J Vet Emerg Crit Care. 2012;22(2):253-261. doi:10.1111/j.1476-4431.2011.00700.x
41 Marx F, Machado G, Pezzali J, et al. Raw beef bones as chewing items to reduce dental calculus in Beagle dogs. Aust Vet J. 2016;94(1-2):18-23. doi:10.1111/avj.12394
42 Steenkamp G, Gorrel C. Oral and Dental Conditions in Adult African Wild Dog Skulls: A Preliminary Report. J Vet Dent. 1999;16(2):65-68. doi:10.1177/089875649901600201
43 Van Valkenburgh B. Incidence of Tooth Breakage Among Large, Predatory Mammals. Am Nat. 1988;131(2):291-302. doi:10.1086/284790
44 VanValkenburgh B, Hertel F. Tough Times at La Brea: Tooth Breakage in Large Carnivores of the Late Pleistocene. Science (80- ). 1993;261(5120):456-459. doi:10.1126/science.261.5120.456
45 Schlesinger DP, Joffe DJ. Raw food diets in companion animals: a critical review. Can Vet J = La Rev Vet Can. 2011;52(1):50-54. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21461207. Accessed October 27, 2018.
46 Investigation into an Outbreak of Shiga Toxin Producing Escherichia Coli (STEC) O157 PT 21/28 Stx2 in England.; 2017. www.facebook.com/PublicHealthEngland. Accessed October 27, 2018.
47 Chengappa MM, Staats J, Oberst RD, Gabbert NH, McVey S. Prevalence of Salmonella in Raw Meat used in Diets of Racing Greyhounds. J Vet Diagnostic Investig. 1993;5(3):372-377. doi:10.1177/104063879300500312
48 Finley R, Ribble C, Aramini J, et al. The risk of salmonellae shedding by dogs fed Salmonella-contaminated commercial raw food diets. Can Vet J = La Rev Vet Can. 2007;48(1):69-75. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17310625. Accessed October 27, 2018.
49 Joffe DJ, Schlesinger DP. Preliminary assessment of the risk of Salmonella infection in dogs fed raw chicken diets. Can Vet J = La Rev Vet Can. 2002;43(6):441-442. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12058569. Accessed October 27, 2018.
50 Weese JS, Rousseau J, Arroyo L. Bacteriological evaluation of commercial canine and feline raw diets. Can Vet J = La Rev Vet Can. 2005;46(6):513-516. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16048011. Accessed October 27, 2018.
51 Strohmeyer RA, Morley PS, Hyatt DR, Dargatz DA, Scorza AV, Lappin MR. Evaluation of bacterial and protozoal contamination of commercially available raw meat diets for dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2006;228(4):537-542. doi:10.2460/javma.228.4.537
Brennen McKenzie, MA, MSc, VMD, cVMA, discovered evidence-based veterinary medicine after attending the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine and working as a small animal general practice veterinarian. He has served as president of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine Association and reaches out to the public through his SkeptVet blog, the Science-Based Medicine blog, and more. He is certified in medical acupuncture for veterinarians. Columnists’ opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Veterinary Practice News.
Comments will be approved before showing up.
Did someone say TREAT?
Subscribe to our mailing list for the latest products & special offers!